Mayonnaise or Miracle Whip?

[eveled]

"Here is one. For mayo on a sandwich do you use a spoon or a butter knife?"View attachment 79137

I have the Buck version it is ideal for bagels and cream cheese. Also great for avocados.

 

[s4s4u]

Here is one. For mayo on a sandwich do you use a spoon or a butter knife?

I very much prefer a spoon for this task. Same for PB and Jelly.

Neither. My mayo I buy in the upside-down squeeze jug, like a mustard container. Squirt, squirt, squirt....

 

[GSP7]

miracle wip

I just scored some " sandwich spread " at a new super walmart in Eagle mtn Utah

Has even more tasty stuff in it

 

[375hh1973]

Neither

Both are disgusting.

Add ranch dressing to that as well.

I once threw a sandwich on the floor in a restaurant in Ludington, MI because of mayonnaise

 

[Kevin]

Neither

Both are disgusting.

Add ranch dressing to that as well.

I once threw a sandwich on the floor in a restaurant in Ludington, MI because of mayonnaise

I bet that made you real popular with the waitress.

Opposite that, remember the TV commercial where the guy threw away the sandwich he made because for the final step, adding Miracle Whip, the jar was empty. No Miracle Whip, No Sammy.

 

[375hh1973]

I bet that made you real popular with the waitress.

Opposite that, remember the TV commercial where the guy threw away the sandwich he made because for the final step, adding Miracle Whip, the jar was empty. No Miracle Whip, No Sammy.

Had ordered a club sandwich, no mayo. Told the waitress explicitly that I hated mayo, please make sure there was no mayo. She said absolutely.

Got my sandwich, took a big bite, full of mayo.

Said a few choice words and tossed it on the floor.

They weren' happy, I wasn't happy, but damn, it created a story that my dad and uncle talked about for years

 

[tazbigdog]

Ok, grew up on Hellmans, but they changed their recipe and never tasted the same.

West coast, Best was the counterpart. Better, but not there.

Tried Duke, better. But still not there.

Anyway, saw this video and am trying these recommended.

 

[peachhead]

I like both, but mayo is Dukes, olive oil usually but sometimes I go whole hog and get the real stuff.
Or as the lady at my old work cafeteria said, "marenaise."

 

[ArizonaTea123]

I mix mayonnaise and hot sauce together in a bowl and dip my fries in it. Spicy

 

[dadstillsurfs]

Mayonnaise is for the inside and outside of Tortas. Don't knock browning a sandwich that has been coated liberally on a griddle or in a skillet. Abuelita knows best!
I reserve Miracle Whip for my peanut butter / banana / Lettuce sandwiches (gotta be on white bread).

 

[gnappi]

I added to my vote of Hellman's and it's Bang Bang sauce. It made with real mayo with hot peppers and goes on / with everything.

 

[gnappi]

I mix mayonnaise and hot sauce together in a bowl and dip my fries in it. Spicy

Try Bang Bang sauce... same same.

 

[GSP7]

SRIRACHA

 

[Silcott]

Mayonnaise only!

I've thrown sandwiches away after just one bit that I ordered not knowing that it came with Miracle Whip on it

 

[MaxMan]

miracle wip

I just scored some " sandwich spread " at a new super walmart in Eagle mtn Utah

Has even more tasty stuff in it

If it's what I think like it . It seems to be 2nd cousin to Russian dressing.

 

[ArizonaTea123]

My son uses Japanese mayonnaise on everything. It's expensive but the taste is the best I've ever experienced. Sushi restaurants use it quite often.

 

[protoolman]

I actually like them both. I get bored every few months and switch. If I was hard pressed I'd say mayo has a little more flavor. I was poor as a child but always had food enough to make an open face sandwich with mayo on one slice of bread.

 

[jules]

Hellman's for the salads, but for sandwiches it's Mustard....spicy brown or yellow don't matter.

 

[txramfan]

Mayo , because its used to make grilled cheese sandwiches. Put your cheese in between 2 slices of bread and then put the mayo on put in a hot nonstick, or cast iron, or whatever you use to make grilled cheese , no mayo inside that would be gross.

 

[Jennygirl]

Was raised in Iowa on Miracle Whip. Loved those Tuna sandwiches and still do. I never put Mayo or Miracle Whip on any other sandwich and ask for no Mayo if eating out, seems oily to me.

 

[protoolman]

Was raised in Iowa on Miracle Whip. Loved those Tuna sandwiches and still do. I never put Mayo or Miracle Whip on any other sandwich and ask for no Mayo if eating out, seems oily to me.

True, I also eat miracle whip for my work lunch a lot on Tuna sandwiches I make in my office with flavored tuna pouches from Wal Mart.

 

[41Dude]

Miracle Whip is what I serve guests when I want them to leave.

 

[Jennygirl]

Miracle Whip is what I serve guests when I want them to leave.

That’s funny!

 

[wheelgun1958]

Duke's

 

[blume357]

Been doing Duke's for years... have to buy local... they make the stuff just down the road from me. But my wife is not supposed to do soy anymore and Dukes has soybean oil in it and so am thinking about switching over to this Chosen brand that is made with Avocado oil. And yes I know Helman's makes an olive oil mayo but if you look at the ingredients it also has soybean oil.

 

[Fox Mike]

No real preference. Either or. Then again I am not a picky eater.

 

[GUNFUNCO]

Mayo on toasted pumpernickle, tomato and thin sliced onion. Miracle Whip on untoasted bread with leftover turkey or chicken. Tuna is good with either, with lettuce, in a pita or your choice of plain or toasted bread. Roast beef with onion and either one as well.

 

[Tenbore]

Whichever lasts longest in the fridge.

 

[Hertervillian]

I’ve tried em all, Hellmans Mayo, the end.

 

[gonepostal]

It seems to me that Miracle Whip is more of a midwest/rural thing. Being from a major city originally, hands down Hellman's only.