Colt Trooper MKV vs. GP100,,,,,,

benchrest500

Single-Sixer
Joined
Feb 17, 2011
Messages
111
Here's your chance,,,, fire away!!


IMG_0196-2.jpg



Still keeping the Colt anyway :D



benchrest500
 
I like the Colt but the barrel is too long for me. I prefer a 4" for that Trooper.

Nice guns none the less.
 
Of THOSE two, I prefer the GP to the too-long Colt.

With either 4" or 6" barrels on both, I'd rather have the Colt.

OTOH, the GP is still in production--easy to get parts and factory service for. The Colt is now an orphan--and one that they didn't make all that many of in the first place. :? I have a King Cobra (same basic gun) right now that's completely out of service due to a broken internal frame pin. I'll have to send it back to Colt to get it fixed--if even THEY can and will do it. :? :? :?
 
For a 357 magnum hunting handgun there are many other choices also. A Ruger Bisley, or Redhawk, or any number of Smiths could fill the bill. I have a Ruger 357 Bisley 7.5" but for hunting anything bigger than a Florida deer I would use a .41 or a .44 magnum. 8) 8)

Targets2.jpg


...Jimbo
 
Yeah the "Cowboy" guns have started to grow on me, don't have any,,, oh this may be a bad thing,,,, :? Good looking gun by the way,,, oh this is getting worse,,,:shock:

but for hunting anything bigger than a Florida deer I would use a .41 or a .44 magnum.

Not sure how big a Florida deer is but I always thought my 44 SRH was WAY too big to use on our Whitetail,,,,, HEY my Colt is a "Whitetailer" we were thinking the same thing!!

I had read where one of the Wesson family had developed the 357 Mag back in the 30's and the original marketing was embossed with his great success of using the round for hunting. But shot placement wins the game,,, I have seen some of these Hillbillys around here pump 5 - 12 ga. slugs in a deer's a$s and then spend the day chasing to poor animal. The first 3 deer I shot with my SRH were vital area shots and it was nothing but carnage inside them so I got more confidence with the gun by working to get a reliable 100 yard group then started shooting them in the head like I was told to do by the Elder men (Dad and Uncles) when I was growing up.

I had always wanted to build a "bench" 357 but never did and the blues were calling this time, stainless getting old on me.

I saw this Colt at a gun show last month and walked away for $950, that spured me to buy the Ruger but for the shooting I like to do the 6" barrel was bugging the sh%t out of me thinking how much I wanted that extra speed of an 8".

Needless to say the Colt was haunting me so I tracked it down and bought it for,,,,,,, $837 not too shabby for a rare Colt from the custom shop.

The scratch looks much worse in the picture than it is.

May get to shoot it later today, give me an idea of what kind of grips I'll put on it,,, Hogue for sure (if I do anything) but not sure of wood or rubber, their rubber grip has the back strap bare, not fond of that. May leave the factory grips but always thought they were quite ugly. So if it's easy on the hand I may Doll her up with some Checkered wood!
 
....extra speed of an 8".

Now that you have them, chronograph both on the same day using the same ammo, and see which is actually 'faster'.

The Remington 180g S-JHP, the 140 / 158 / 180g XTP-HP, the Cast Performance 187g; these bullets often fly true.



I do not believe I will EVER sell my 7.5" 357 Redhawk.
 
Now that you have them, chronograph both on the same day using the same ammo, and see which is actually 'faster'.


The GP100 is brand new, I'm an FFL in Indiana,,, gun is for sale unfired and no plans of changing that. I have it listed in the classifieds here as well ($475). Gun show coming up soon so it will be gone shortly either way.





CutRuger.jpg



Found that magazine that tells it pretty well on speed vs. length once you get to the 6"-8" range the change isn't as much as the shorter lengths, graph shows it well


benchrest500
 
That is an interesting analysis, if a bit sad for the Super Blackhawk :)

I have owned both a Colt Trooper 4" and a GP100 6". I traded off the Trooper and kept the GP100. I preferred its stainless finish, parts availabilty, and I feel it is a stronger gun than the Colt, although I never put it to a destructive test.

Both were equally accurate, and both were equally smooth to shoot (once I put lighter springs in the GP100).
 
Whats with the *** lookin' dude in the red suit in somebodies avatar ? LOL ! Ok, OK, go with the Ruger, if'n ya want to shoot it for a lifetime and then pass it down. steve b
 
That's actually Sean Connery in the movie Zardoz. One of the strangest science fiction movies ever. Although it does feature tons of Webley revolvers and Enfield rifles.

After watching that movie, you will never look at James Bond in quite the same way again :)

Back on topic: Go with the Ruger!

steve b said:
Whats with the *** lookin' dude in the red suit in somebodies avatar ? LOL ! Ok, OK, go with the Ruger, if'n ya want to shoot it for a lifetime and then pass it down. steve b
 
Yep, that's Zed from Zardoz. I'd suggest finding a copy of the novelization - it'll make more sense. ;)

You don't see many of those Peacekeepers, much less the Whitetailer version. I've got the 6" version.........

GunList018.jpg
 
I'm with wellfedirishman on this one. I've always liked the looks of the Trooper MKIII, and owned two of them, one in 4" and one in 6"bbl. I have since sold both Colts and acquired a new GP100 stainless in 5"bbl. After changing out the trigger and hammer springs, the GP is magnificent.
 
wellfedirishman said:
That's actually Sean Connery in the movie Zardoz. One of the strangest science fiction movies ever. Although it does feature tons of Webley revolvers and Enfield rifles.

After watching that movie, you will never look at James Bond in quite the same way again :)

Back on topic: Go with the Ruger!

steve b said:
Whats with the *** lookin' dude in the red suit in somebodies avatar ? LOL ! Ok, OK, go with the Ruger, if'n ya want to shoot it for a lifetime and then pass it down. steve b



Yeah it was that pic or Jr. from Reno 911 I always laugh when I see that pic of Sean Connery


.
 
I have a gp100 with 4" bbl that I love. it's the perfect size and feels great in your hand. Rugers are often looked down on by S&W fans but to me they are a lot better made guns.
 
Back
Top