No, if it is moving on its own it indicates to me the the ball detent is not working correctly.
From what you describe it sounds like it might be "gunked up".
I would suggest, move to the 3-9 position,
Remove the base pin/loading assembly & cylinder.
Give the latch pin a good dose of WD-40. The WD-40 is only being used as a solvent and slight lubricant at this point.
With a brass punch drive the pin from left to right, in other words the punch should be on the non screw head side.
Once you get it out give the thing a long soak in WD-40 or a good solvent to get the grease from the ball out. Also clean up the area on the gun itself. I personally like WD-40 as a solvent for the cleaning.
Wipe it down clean and I librally re-lube with Break-Free.
Line the the pin back in the 3-9 position and usually you can persuade a clean pin back in with just finger pressure, but if need be, use what ever is non-marring to drive it back thru. It should re-install much easier than it came out, if it is clean and the ball is not stuck still.
Now it should click into the OPEN position 3-9 and the CLOSED position 1-7 with a clear and concise detent position.
When operating the screw/pin you will learn when the screw head is lined up with the base pin it's open and when it's crossed the base pin it's closed, like a gate valve.
Note: I have been overly specific here with dis/re-assembly instructions as this is a common problem with Ruger Old Army's and others will read read this.
It has been a long time fact that the Old Army was one of Bill Ruger's favorites. As I have admired, used, taken apart, fixed, re-built these over the years they are special in simplicity of design. A day spent a field enjoying burnt black powder with these guns is truly a good day.