Another impactful passing...

wolfsong

Moderator
Staff member
Moderator
Joined
Dec 20, 2005
Messages
2,873
City & State/Province
Sierra foothills, Ca. U.S.A.
In order to avoid hijacking Volshooter's thread, I'll share this here. Your input is appreciated.

Backgound: my Lady owns a couple of cars, one of them a 2008 Chevy Impala. It blew the intake manifold gasket, so we took to a mechanic, Joey, who has been good to me for over 20 years. He has always been honest, up front and not adverse to saving me money by letting me provide replacement parts and simply doing the labor. I have always trusted him. He operates a small shop, basically him and a couple of young grease monkeys who do oil changes, tune-ups, etc. He does all of the major work. Takes awhile, but his work has always been top notch.

So, he's got the Impala torn apart for an $900 estimated job, parts and labor included. Yesterday, I had a message on my phone from one of his workers to call him on his cell phone number rather than his shop number, so I did. An uncle of his answered and informed me that Joey passed away suddenly on Sunday. He said I had to get the Impala out of the shop by the end of the week and pay the outstanding balance of $500. Today, I stopped by the shop to check things out and make arrangements to have the car towed to another mechanic. Problem is, the motor looks like a gang of Vikings pillaged it. Top end completely dismantled, parts here, parts there, just a mess. His helpers are of no help whatsoever. No way to tell what's what. The uncle is demanding the $500 or he won't release the vehicle. The vehicle is useless without knowing what has been done and where the scattered parts are. On top of that, i'd have to pay another mechanic to start all over even if I could figure it all out. So, basically, i'm left with a pile of junk. I might be able to get $200 From the local Pick N Pull yard. And we had replaced the A/C compressor and the fuel pump within the last 8 months, so there's some good money put into it. Has just over 90k original miles on it.

I really don't know what recourse I have, if any. I know it's just money. I am sad that I lost a good friend and a trusted mechanic, and I feel bad for his family. At the same time, I am discouraged by the circumstances. I know that it's a $3000 vehicle at best, but neither mama nor I have an extra 3 grand laying around. Oh, well.

Any suggestions?
 
Lawyer up! Usually the 1st consultation is free. Years ago I had a serious family issue. A lawyer told what the law was, not what I wanted to hear. That was worth it's weight in gold.

I'm sorry you and J are going thru this. Been there with lawyers, but they sure can ease the stress. Get one!
 
My condolences on your loss.

Shifting gears (no pun intended) now it's a business transaction.

You need a lawyer.

My non lawyer advice is if the car is worth $3000 they can pay you $2500 and keep it. They've turned it into a $1000 car "as is".

Did I mention you need to know your legal rights?

Good luck.
 
Reminds me of a cartoon I seen. This guy swam up to a dock and is telling the guy helping him out of the water, Damn! I lost my boat, motor and tackle! Old Charley`s gone too!
That is a mess! Good luck with it.
 
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change.
Yep... Lawyer time. Sometimes initial consultations are free.. Other times a hundred bucks. I would certainly invest the price for the consultation. Figure 2K for a minimum retainer to get started if you want them to do the work. The car might be worth what, 2500 bucks in running order? The trouble is that it was broken when it got there, and there WAS work done on it, albeit not completed.

So I think Hittman is on the right track.

A completely screwed up situation you got there... :( It's one of those cases where the cost to recover will probably exceed the value of the property.

Good luck,
Regards, Pete
 
Sorry about the loss of your friend.
It is my understanding that repair shops should carry insurance for unexpected liabilities like this. Things happen from time to time even in the best of shops. Vehicle theft, accidental damage, etc. Unless your friend was a shade tree mechanic, I bet he had some sort of insurance. Follow up promptly. I realize that your car doesn't have a huge amount of book value, but that is really not the issue. If the car was a 2015, worth $20,000, and was in for the same repair, I bet you wouldn't be willing to accept that situation. Good luck.
 
I'm sorry for your loss of a friend Sir..

Having said this, I've run into this situation before myself.. I agree 100% with others here that say it is time to talk with a lawyer on this issue.. Now, I realize every state has their own laws and ways of dealing with things. however, here in Idaho, whomever now legally owns the business has also taken on the responsibility of completing the work per the written estimate.. Whether they like it or not.. Buying, or inheriting a business out here, means you also inherit all the issues that go along with it..

Don't like it? Tough.. That's the law.. You got the business, now you finish it..

Sounds to me, like his family really doesn't give a damn about him as much as the money.. Typical vultures to me that don't care if they screw someone over.. So long as they profit by it..

Either way, talk to a lawyer right away..
 
If it were mine, I would find another mechanic first and a lawyer second. I'd get a court order to recover the car and all parts. Take the mechanic to the shop with you and let him recover the parts to take with him to his shop. Deduct that expense from the $500 the shop is charging. Tell the lawyer what you want beforehand, he will advise what is fair and legal. You did not cause this situation, the greedy relative did.
 
Show up with a tow truck and the cops to retrieve YOUR PROPERTY right now. Get it out of there.

The shop can file a mechanics lien against you later to pursue getting their $500 if they want.
 
I would NOT MOVE the vehicle til a lawyer tells you. The shop is liable for the estimated work. You don’t OWE them anything at this point, since all that they have done at this point is devalue your vehicle. Good luck!
gramps
 
gramps said:
I would NOT MOVE the vehicle til a lawyer tells you. The shop is liable for the estimated work. You don’t OWE them anything at this point, since all that they have done at this point is devalue your vehicle. Good luck!
gramps


Agreed.
 
Doc Holliday said:
Show up with a tow truck and the cops to retrieve YOUR PROPERTY right now. Get it out of there.

Hi,

Good way to cause more problems than get solved. I dunno a tow company around here that would take that job without appropriate paperwork, and it's hard enough to get our cops to even respond to real crime calls, so you'd probably go broke on donuts just trying to bait them. Call a lawyer: sometimes they actually earn their keep. And BAR was mentioned: in CA that's not the first outfit most mechanics would choose to tangle with.

Rick C
 
You may need to sue for the blue book value of the vehicle, and let the shop have the car. If you win, and you probably will, that might teach the new owner a lesson in civics and good manners. Sometimes, you gotta smack them in the side of the head.
 
mistermills357 said:
You may need to sue for the blue book value of the vehicle, and let the shop have the car. If you win, and you probably will, that might teach the new owner a lesson in civics and good manners. Sometimes, you gotta smack them in the side of the head.

Agreed..

Sometimes the only thing people understand and respect, is when it hits them in the wallet.. Otherwise, they don't take you seriously..

It's like Poker.. If you ain't dealing from strength, you just ain't dealing..
 

Latest posts

Back
Top