I will readily admit to being a Ruger junkie.
That said,,,, I too own "other brands" and I attend the SHOT Show, I own a gun range, shoot USPSA competition, certified as a Range Officer, Teach NRA classes etc. I have a bit of experience with not just Rugers, but a broad base of firearms.
I also understand business a bit.
In business,,, there is supply & demand.
Lipsey's has been wonderful, especially Jason, at looking at our posts & studying the desires of shooters to bring us guns we want. Remember the 44 Spl Flattop? How many OM 357's were being converted to 44 spl before this happened? Thanks Jason!
Look at the current 327 Single-Seven. Compare it to the .327 Blackhawk. The Blackhawk came out & some folks whined & cried wanting it on the Single-Six sized frame. I found it to be a SWEET shooter,,, but it has been dropped. So, Jason has gotten Ruger to build a 327 on the Single-Six frame size & still people whine. Many want the longer chamber for heavier bullets & are complaining the current bullets they cast for 327's are too long. The issue of pressures was addressed by making it a 7 shot, so folks wouldn't complain about a 5 shot cylinder. (Think bolt notch here.)
My point is no matter what, you can't please everyone all the time. But Jason sure DOES listen to us here & tries to get certain guns built to satisfy our desires. KUDOS Jason! (You have to be realistic from a business standpoint as well as having something built w/o major technical changes by Ruger.)
A lot of what I've seem many folks complain about is the fit or finish of a Ruger. A tool mark here or there. Slight differences in grip to frame fit. These are but two of the "normal" complaints I see. Look at what Bill Ruger built his company on AND the current motto; "Rugged, reliable firearms." Key word here is "RUGGED!" If you want a perfect fit & finish, as mentioned, pony up the extra $$ & buy a FA. I happen to own both & yes, the fit, finish & all are much nicer than a production Ruger. I have had the pleasure of touring the FA plant & know how they spend TIME paying attention to details. (Business 101; time costs money.)
Anybody recall the fact that way back when, Bill had cosmetic issues with frames & parts turning plum colored? Folks complained & returned guns to the factory. Bill re-blued them & returned them. Now, plum guns are desired by many collectors. It cost Bill $$$$ every time one was returned.
Another post in a different section by a new member asked about tooling marks on his gun. He took a blown up, very close up pic of a small mark, that appeared to be highlighted by a marker to see it. Not to belittle the new member, but I looked closely at the fit of the frame to trigger housing. The very faint line where the two mated showed a very custom looking fit. I have seen worse marks on new guns from handling by gun shop bozo than the one he was complaining about. (What about the turn ring on cylinders caused by the same bozo's?)
Next, let's look at the other part of the motto; "reliable." If the gun doesn't shoot, or has functioning issues, by all means, AS NOTED ABOVE, a polite call to Ruger is in order.
Nobody,,,, AND I MEAN NOBODY is perfect. Not me, nor anybody else here. Be honest, to those of you who work in a trade where you have to build or craft something. When you first started out, did you always turn out perfect parts or product every time, all the time? I doubt it. We ALL had to learn how to make our work better. Go to any manufacturing plant & one of the constant issues is "how much scrap or rejects" an employee makes is a serious concern. A new employee will have a higher rate of problems as an experienced person. And sometimes, a part or product gets out the door with a few issues. Ruger does a test firing of each gun, but not 200-500 rounds. Problems arise a lot once a gun gets sold & the owner fires more than a couple of rounds. (Base pin walking is an example.) Often an easy fix, and not as common as many would believe. I happen to own (currently) well north of 100 Ruger SA revolvers. I have added exactly ONE Belt Mtn base pin to a gun. And ONLY because I wanted the custom Keith type look. I have had exactly two guns where the base pin wanted to walk forward. Both times I found the screw loose, causing the spring to be weaker. Once tightened properly, NO issues. I used to think I was getting defective guns because I didn't get base pin walk.
But,,, I can also attest to a few defects in a few guns I got from Ruger.
I'm one of the RARE folks who had a Redhawk barrel separate from the frame. In fact I was told that I was the very first person to have this happen.
Ruger customer service took care of the problem, quite nicely too.
I also had one of the newer SR9 semi's that had barrel peening at the hood.
Once again, customer service took care of things.
I also had one of the early P85's that Ruger recalled & upgraded the safety.
Once again, customer service took care of things.
I currently have a 22/45 MKIII LITE that has had the scope base screws strip out. Using the correct torque as recommended too. I haven't even bothered to contact Ruger yet, as I'm deciding if I want to ship it back or fix it myself.
I'm sure customer service will once again take care of me if I choose to send it back.
I've bought many NM Rugers over the years, and while I've seen grip fit issues, or other minor cosmetic issues on a few, I understand business enough to know that I can not expect a custom gun at a production price.
I also understand that NOBODY in the distributors are going to hand inspect each & every firearm they get in. (Business 101; time costs money.) Besides, who's to say an inspector there is going to know what to look for in all the various models & makes they sell?
Next, many, many consumers want a product they can afford. It all boils down to MONEY.
Many consumers will buy a new gun based a LOT on price, brand be darned. We here on the Ruger Forum, as well as the folks who enjoy Colt's, S&W, SIG, etc all are a bit more brand loyal & know a bit more than the higher percentage of average gun buyers.
I have lost count at the number of people who have bought a Heritage Arms 22 SA revolver over a Ruger. Or a Hi-Point over a Taurus. ALL because of $$$$$$$$$$$$!
And a lot of these same folks are perfectly happy with their purchase, because it's what they could afford. As people can afford more, they look for a bit better gun, (or anything) for that matter.
If we as consumers get any product that is bad, we go back to the manufacturer to get it fixed, not the distributors.
Nobody, & I mean NOBODY produces a man made product perfectly 100% of the time. Only God's creations are perfect, and I see too many folks question some of those as well.
Do I expect a perfect product? No. Do I expect a functioning product? Yes. My expectations are realistic. I pay for a production line assembled product accordingly & I pay for a custom product accordingly.
I buy a Chevy over a Ferrari.
I buy Rugers more often over Freedom Arms.
I understand business & manufacturing.
If I have a problem, I'll got to the maker, not the distributor.
If I want as close to perfection as possible, I'll pay a custom price.
I'm a realist.