what Ty says, we've seen the same range around here and it HAS to be in the 'original' packaging to get anywhere near those prices, most here ,used, no package go in the $40-60 range, wish I could get $75 for one (used) but nice shape................when we had the shop we had them ALL, right hand ,left hand, bagged, boxed, whatever and never got more than the 'retail' of $18.50 and were stuck with many of them, took a LONG time to sell them as they would literally "eat" the bluing' off a blued steel revolver........bottom line , we used them for "display" purposes ONLY,,,,,,,, NEVER carried a gun in one.
We even had the Buckeye Special version, both in brown AND black, was nice to 'know' the old man (John) down there at Buckeye Sports ( Johns Shooting Supplies) in Canton,Oh