Reloading for SD practice.

meshugunner

Single-Sixer
Joined
May 19, 2012
Messages
270
City & State/Province
New Mexico
I carry high quality factory ammo - never handloads - but at $1+ a piece I can't do much practice with that ammo. I'm thinking to handload rounds with similar bullet shape and weight and setting the powder charge to match the muzzle velocity of the factory ammo. I have a chronograph. Does this make sense?
 
Probably more important than matching muzzle velocity is matching point of impact. Using a bullet of the same weight will likely give you a recoil impulse that feels the same. You need to match recoil "good enough". You want to get the POI dead on to your carry load (if I understand what you are trying to accomplish).
 
Most of my SD/HD ammo is Hornady factory load. I've always liked their stuff. It's also easy for me to make a round as close to factory as possible with spent brass and a fresh Hornady bullet, Hornady bullets are available everywhere. I have clone loads in 9mm and .45ACP and I make sure I set them to a factory length and profile. It's kinda fun and they make great practice/target rounds.
 
I bought several thousand "pulled" bullets matching my carry load bullets. Loaded to similar velocity, they provide exactly the same POI, recoil, and function vs my carry ammo. Economical and in real life terms, identical . Actually, I keep a backup mag loaded with the handloads to use when disposing of varmints.
 
Those are very good ideas. Thank you. I will choose a round for which the bullets are available and load those for practice. Hornady sounds like a good choice. It would also mean I could make up some dummy rounds to practice revolver reloads. Some of those HPs are tricky to insert with a speedloader.

I will also load up some of my cast bullets to match POA for cheap practice.

I am reluctant to use handloads for SD. I have heard it can cause legal complications if I actually shoot someone with it. Also, I am new to reloading and I don't have as much confidence in my handloads as I do in factory ammo.
 
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change.
It is easy to come up with a good handload that duplicates or is a very close approximation of most factory loads, and an excellent idea for practice. In some cases, I use factory ammo when I cannot obtain the specific bullet type as a separate component or obtain better ballistics and performance than factory ammo because of the powders available to them. But for other cartridges, e.g. 44 Special, I am not at all reluctant to use handloads if that is what works best. From a simple perspective, I don't subscribe to the issue of legal complications unless someone tries to construct an "exotic" load (you know, ridiculous sorts of things like backwards bullets, fill the hollowpoint with mercury, dip it in vampire killling garlic, etc). And I know enough lawyers familiar with firearms laws, acting as both defense and prosecution, some of whom are accomplished handloaders and also carry their own defensive handloads. I have full confidence in the ammo I put together myself, exercising meticulous care to do so considering its importance of function. Plus, I can shoot a lot of it for practice and know it is *exactly* the stuff I carry. But that's just me. For the common answer to the common question, who wouldn't say "carry only factory" as generic advice? And since you are new to handloading and express that you haven't developed as much confidence in your handloads yet as factory, that is certainly the right position to take.
 
I recently picked up a chronograph mainly so that I could match SD rounds with handloads. I started reloading so that I could shoot a lot - which I do - and so I reload a lot but you have to know the horse you are riding and in my case, I don't think I will ever get to the point where I would bet my life on my work.

As for the current wisdom of using handloads for SD because of legal implications, I think what I heard probably does originate with Ayoob and yes, he is one of those blowhard opinionators that I generally have little respect for. But a couple of things do concern me: While I don't see shooting someone with my handloads as enough by itself to cause problems, it might could combine with other elements to support the narrative depicted by a prosecutor or a plaintiffs attorney. I am more worried about the latter where the burden of proof is much lower. Also, I am wary of using common sense to predict legal consequences when I know very little about the law. I know from my own area of expertise that I routinely hear people with no training apply common sense reasoning to this subject and reach conclusions that are spectacularly wrong. I am not arguing a universal prescription. This is a matter of taking a risk and each person must decide for himself what he can accept.

Garlic eh? Now there's an idea! I could do one round in garlic, one in olive oil and a third in balsamic vinegar. Death by vinegrette!
Again thanks for the comments and advice.
 
I do but the loading process is very different than my plinkin or hunting ammo.

There are many threads on this very subject.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top