Yes, I am a plow handle person myself.... But when it comes to shooting the 'heavy' loads, the Bisley just 'works' better. Since I rarely shoot heavy (and I mean 'heavy'), the plow handle revolvers get the first call. Those with extra large hands seem to prefer the Bisley as well. I don't consider the .357 ever needing the Bisley grip, but that is just me. Until you get to the big bore, the Bisley is more of a 'personal' preference.