First I recommend you noy buy something temporary, find what you like and just buy once.
Also I always spring for a lined holster; py a little more but really saves the gun finish, even stainless!
Third, it sounds like yo're interested in a traditional/western style.
Hard to beat Reddog leather for price and service. They'll make anything, anyway you like! Here's their ebay store: https://www.ebay.com/str/reddogleather
Texas Jack (affiliated with Cimarron Firearms) is another: https://www.texasjacks.com/products/gun-leather/holsters/holster-cheyenne-double-loop-lined.html
I also use El Paso but can be a little more pricey. It all depends on what you see that you like.