Ruger & Hy Hunter compared...

Bob Wright

Hawkeye
Joined
Jun 24, 2004
Messages
8,597
City & State/Province
Memphis, TN USA
Been working on my newly acquired Hy Hunter .357 Magnum. While handling the gun, it felt considerably heavier and more massive than my Rugers. So decided to get out my New Model .357 Blackhawk, now fitted with a Super Blackhawk grip frame.

100_0006-3.jpg


It dawned on me that the gun felt heavier because it is a .357 Magnum while I've been accustomed of late to 4 3/4" or 4 5/8" barreled .44s and .45s, both on the medium frame. Certainly it'll be more massive.

But, compared to my Ruger New Model BBlackhawk, there is really not much difference. I removed the cylinders and there is scant difference in diameters. Length not so, as the Ruger cylinder is considerably shorter, though slightly longer through the ratchet/cylinder bushing O.A.L. The Ruger has a much greater barrel protrusion than the Hy Hunter.

The Ruger feel much better in dry-firing, with its wider trigger and gentler hammer fall. The Hy Hunter has a good trigger, but that mainspring sure drives the hammer forward. Haven't been able to fire them side-by-side yet, the Ruger is sighted in, while the Hy Hunter has not yet been sighted in, shooting about six inches low at fifty feet.

Thought ya'll might be interested. Incidentally, this is the way the Hy Hunter appears now:

100_0139.jpg


Bob Wright
 
For a .357 that has a big cylinder! Looks great with the new grip frame and your home made grips, first rate sir!
 
Wow! Bob, You cleaned that gun up very nice! 100% improvement on looks.
What are you using for the brass frame? What gun make/model did that come from?
 
NorEaster said:
Wow! Bob, You cleaned that gun up very nice! 100% improvement on looks.
What are you using for the brass frame? What gun make/model did that come from?


I was given that trigger guard as being from a Colt 1851 Navy. However, after chencking the screws, I believe it came from a Uberti. The mainspring screw was a 10-24 thread, which surprised me, and the bottom backstrap screw is from an Uberti. I bought a Hy Hunter backstrap from Numrich Gun Parts Corp., which required a little filing to mate it up. As far as I know, brass trigger guards and backstraps for the Hawes Western Marshall are available and would have fit, but I already had the trigger guard in my parts box.


Here as original trial fit:

100_0067.jpg


And after a little filing and polishing:

100_0046.jpg



Bob Wright
 
Nice Job! Growing up, I used to look at the Western Auto catalog and dream of having a Hawes SA someday
 

Latest posts

Back
Top