5of7 said:I have always considered the Ruger revolver to be a sturdier gun than the Smith, and economically, a better buy for the dollar.
I have also always considered the Smiths to be better finished and all-round "nicer" guns....with a few exceptions. 8)
trouble said:not like the new garbage they are marketing
DonD said:trouble said:not like the new garbage they are marketing
You're entitled to your opinion but calling new S&W guns garbage is simply BS. People with far greater knowledge than you will tell you that while they may lack the hand polishing of earlier models, they are made of stronger materials held to tighter tolerances.
Strong?? Don't know anything that matches the raw strength of the S&W Model 500s. One of their engineers told me he thought it would take 130,000 psi to take one apart. Don
trouble said:DonD said:trouble said:not like the new garbage they are marketing
You're entitled to your opinion but calling new S&W guns garbage is simply BS. People with far greater knowledge than you will tell you that while they may lack the hand polishing of earlier models, they are made of stronger materials held to tighter tolerances.
Strong?? Don't know anything that matches the raw strength of the S&W Model 500s. One of their engineers told me he thought it would take 130,000 psi to take one apart. Don
As you're entitled to your foolishly blind opinion sir, new smiths are pure garbage and I'm a S&W guy and have been for a long time, I've had MANY smiths go through my hands in the past 20 yrs so my opinion is based on what I've seen NOT blind emotion. BS is what folks like yourself spout off.
Funny, you can find threads here making exactly the same claim about Rugers, that the current ones have very poor QC and finish compared to those from "back in the day", when ever that was.trouble said:Not a fair comparison, pinned Smiths come from Smiths best era, not like the new garbage they are marketing. New Smith to new Ruger? No question, Ruger any day, all day long. Just got a 12 production GP100 myself, but an older pinned Smith? I do believe I'd take the Smith juts on resale value alone, old Smiths are crazy expensive!