High End Cooler Quest

Cholo

Moderator
Staff member
Moderator
Joined
Dec 30, 2008
Messages
11,198
City & State/Province
Georgia
I borrowed a 70 quart discount house Igloo cooler for my 9 week vacation last year. I had to feed that thing ice non stop. I plan on getting out and about as soon as the weather cools a bit so it was time to get a cooler that will keep stuff cold for about 5 days. Lots of coolers and accessories are out of stock; I guess they can blame it on the Rona.

I've been researching the different brands for about a week. I really didn't want to buy a Yeti after their NRA fiasco. I don't believe Yeti is anti NRA, but their timing really sucked when they dropped their discount program the same time other big names were. I looked at and researched just about every brand and when it came to having it all, Yeti came out on top every single time, and they're priced accordingly. Yeti is a bit tight lipped, but sources say their Tundra series is built in the Philippines. Strike 2, NRA was strike 1.

RTIC coolers look good for the $, but they're made in China. Plus their dry goods racks that fit in the top of the coolers were out of stock. I won't have a cooler without a rack or two. China :x

I really liked what ORCA had to offer, and they're not cheap, either! 100% USA made with USA materials in Nashville, TN or Streetsboro, Ohio. Huge thumb's up! One problem: I need the drain plug to be on the right for easy draining out the side door of the van, and ORCA has them on the left side :( The rubber non stick feet on these high end coolers really stick which would make it difficult to turn 180* for draining. Bummer because I liked their taller style 58 quart model because I use it for a seat when changing clothes. Yeti's tall cooler that I like is their Tundra 105 which is actually about 84 quarts.

I call ORCA. Yes, the 58 qt. all drain on the left. Shipping would be from Nashville in about 5 days. Are the cooler feet sticky? No. Cool! That means I can turn the cooler on the rubber mat in my van.

I still wanted to go back and look at the Yeti's. I sure did like that 105, but it's bigger than I need and--Yeti.

If you search something on the web you'll have ads on Facebook for those products until you click on them to go away. There was a 15% off code for all Orca products by an outside company . Nice! Again I went and looked at the Yetis and one ORCA. Those Yeti's are so nice, but Yeti. I came home and filled out everything to get the USA made ORCA 58 with accessories. The 15% code worked! I've never seen a Yeti code. It was ready to submit and I hesitated. 30 minutes later and there's a 25% off all ORCA products code from ORCA. I ordered. For anyone looking the code is DON25. It probably only lasts for a short time.

ORCA--100% made in the USA and a partner with the NRA! Do I think the ORCA is every bit as good as the Yeti? No, but it's close enough. The real world difference in price though I'm comparing a 58 quart ORCA with a 25% discount to an 84 quart Yeti--$268.

If you don't want to buy from Yeti, and you don't want to buy one made in China, you might want to look at the ORCA's. Plus, ORCA has a lifetime warranty and Yeti's is 5 years. That didn't influence my decision, but...

https://orcacoolers.com/collections/58-quart/products/tan-58-cooler
 
I think you found the best one. Orcas, RTIC, etc. All excellent products. Wal-Mart carries two China knock offs that are actually just as good at keeping things cool. Not a lot of racks or options though.
 
Grizzly coolers are made in Decorah, Iowa.
https://www.grizzlycoolers.com/

The same company has a slightly downgraded line as well, under the Kenai name. (Edit: thanks, Cholo! :mrgreen:) https://www.kenaigear.com/

IIRC, the primary difference is in the latch system- the Kenai line doesn’t offer the bear-resistant certification that the Grizzly line has.

Just a few more options...
https://usamadeproducts.biz/outdoor-recreation-camping-gear-coolers.html
(Looks like Amazon sponsors the link, but they’re also available elsewhere.)
 
Cholo:
Thanks for thinking of a USA product. I try to buy American products more and more. It’s important, especially these days with so many people unemployed.

Pelican makes nice coolers, made here in the USA.

There is also a nice roto cooler made in Idaho https://cordovaoutdoors.com/

Last March I bought a smaller roto-molded cooler from Wal Mart. It is made in the USA. Lifetime. Is the brand. Not as nice as the brands you are talking about. But not as expensive and lots smaller.

So!! :D ??? Where are you thinking of heading? Be sure and post pictures!
 
smaller might be better... if you didn't keep that other cooler packed with either items or ice then it will melt quicker.... Also, I'd consider a couple of blocks of ice over the chucks of bagged ice to start with on the bottom...

Yeti made in the Philippines ... at least that's better than China.... but if the Orca is made here I think it is a no brainer... hell just buy two! Heck consider buying two slightly smaller ones and pack both and don't open the other one for a week...

Now that I know about Orcas... next time I need a cooler I know where to go... thanks..

I'll have to check out Pelican... I've bought two of those to pack guns and gear in when I flew out to Front Sight....
 
Dan, with me that wouldn't work, but I did look into the idea. A special drain plug with a hose adapter is made, but I don't know if it would fit the ORCA. With 100% certainty it would leak or I'd break the adapter and flood the van. It wasn't worth the chance, and since the one I bought has hard feet, it won't be too difficult to turn 180* to drain it. With left draining sticky feet only? I wouldn't have bothered and would have bought something else.

Kevin, Pelican's are really nice and obviously they're the ones who make Bass Pro/Cabellas coolers. Size matters and the Pelican's are quite bulky for the capacity with their molded in handles on the top. That just wouldn't work with my limited interior van space.

Where am I heading? Where I can get away from the insanity and see woods and mountain streams full of smallmouth bass I can wade fish for. In the winter I can fish for trout, but my main interest is smallmouth bass. Like trout, around here they pretty much live only in cool clear water, meaning the type places I want to be. Primitive camping is not an issue when in national forest land. I'll live out of the van, no tents for me LOL :)

blume, too big was a big concern after price and made in the USA. Air space, as you said, is the enemy of ice retention. It took me a while to decide the 58 quart size seemed perfect for me. After reading literally dozens of reviews, many I disgarded completely for obvious BS, I came to the conclusion that ORCA was as close in quality to a Yeti as anything else. They're proud of the USA made with all USA made materials! China was out simply because--China.

BTW: OTD with 2 dry baskets, an extra drain plug, and 4 sticky rubber feet covers I can use or not, $311 after the 25% discount. The non discounted Yeti 105 (84 quart) with one extra basket (it comes with one) and a divider that ORCA doesn't offer would have been $579. I sure didn't want to spend that much. I got an email this AM that it will be delivered Monday. That's fast in the cooler world!
 
I didn't see Canyon Coolers on the list of USA companies, they're made here in AZ.
Here's some side by side comparisons https://www.coolersonsale.com/canyon-coolers-review/#:~:text=About%20Canyon%20Coolers,quality%20coolers%20to%20professional%20outfitters.
 
Glad that you were able to make a choice & buy American.

Seems every time I watch a cooler comparison there is a different winner. If runners up, & one was American? No brainer.
 
I'm also glad you bought American, i think you will come to appreciate that even more as time goes by. And as far as Yeti is concerned, i have not researched it, but i recall that at the time of the "scandal", just about everyone was saying that they were anti 2nd amendment, but i am not 100% sure. Anyway, as far as i know, they never gave a press release and said anything like "not us!! no, we are pro-gun, always on your side, fellas"!!!!! Enjoy your cooler!
 
As noted,, Orca makes excellent, American made coolers.

Yeti.
I personally was involved in the FoNRA events,, where Yeti had made a commitment to supply coolers for the FoNRA events,, and then stopped it. It left a lot of events scrambling to meet their obligations to donors & attendees who had been promised a Yeti.
Anti-gun?
I've not seen a direct comment from them,, but as the old saying goes; "Actions speak louder than words!"
By their actions,, they stopped supporting a vital non-profit division of the NRA shooting sports programs.
I no longer support Yeti, nor do I own any of their stuff.
I DO own a Grizzly I got at a FoNRA event after the Yeti decision.
 
I'm like Contender and won't support them... also for the simple reason all the Yuppies here in Greenville love there stuff.. heck it's even sold at the hardware store just up the road....

With that said, I do own a Yeti large insulated drink cup... the reason is a few years back one of the members here were selling them with the Ruger Logo stenciled on them.
 
Bought my big mower and was given a Yeti 24 filled with assorted swag from the mower company. Gifted it to my daughter for when they travel with the grandchild. Was gonna replace it with a larger one until they (Yeti) got stupid.....
Was at the NRA convention in Dallas and discovered the Orca brand. Works great, made in USA.....and the guy gave me three of their 27 oz. drink cups with the purchase.
On a side note, I entered a Grand Opening contest at a local Whataburger and won an Igloo cooler in Whataburger livery. It fits on the back floorboard and works well for toting a couple of gallons of milk from the store so they stay cool, clean and don't tip over.
And while it is nothing that I would buy (for various reasons) this is available if your hauling around gold bars that need to be kept cool....... :roll:

https://www.sportsmans.com/camping-gear-supplies/coolers-storage/extreme-duty-coolers/yeti-tundra-420-cooler/p/1398368
 
Don’t forget Cordova Coolers. They are made in the USA as well.

https://cordovaoutdoors.com/


Charlie
 
Rtic coolers are identical to Yeti coolers. I'm certain they are made on the same assembly lines and come from the same molds as Yeti coolers.

Not long ago, my wife won a drawing from the Iowa Cattlemen's Association. The prize was a 45 can Yeti cooler and 100 dollars in beef certificates, redeemable at most stores in Iowa for beef.

We have a couple in our dog training club that have an Rtic 45 cooler, and they are identical except for the logo. Even the mold sprue excesses were the same where the parts came out of the molds.

The difference? about 1/3 the price for the Rtic.

I would prefer to buy American, but this cooler was free. I will say that it is a fine cooler, and keeps ice for days, but I would never buy one for the price they charge, even without the controversy. YMMV.
 
Back
Top