Pinky under for me most of the time, enough so I voted #1. Small hands and can go either way on some grips and occasionally switch off position but not enough to vote "both." I've got several very nice customs from Carl "Private" Shultz, all beveled - but like Cary, make sure to tell him (or after dealing with me probably Carl's first question now!) as I gather flat is the default. Like someone else posted, the stock Colts amazingly regardless of Gen, though they varied from the 1st Gens on, or USFAs are just about right for me in all regards. The stock (overall) size of the midframe Rugers would be ok too, basically cloning the SAA frame, if Ruger hadn't rid them almost entirely of the SAA bell profile (viewed on end, back to front).