Any other 1911 holster? I don't agree. There are too many worthwhile options and features, that may or may not suit any given person. Sure. You could carry a Commander-size in a full length holster, but then lose the shorter length advantage of the Commander-size.
The sky is the limit on 1911 holsters, so that's why 1911 owners have an assortment. Always looking for the most perfect compromise. A Galco Fletch, or any of the the makers making the same holster is a pretty good choice for me. High riding. Close fitting. No extra "wasted" holster hanging past the slide. And retention. Also always important to me.
Then to consider a more high-tech option...I've found the Blackhawk! Serpa to be my go to holster. Height of carry is adjustable. Cant is adjustable. Belt loop size is adjustable. Very rigid. The downside is it's a bit offset from your waste. A compromise I'm comfortable with.
My short list is not all-inclusive. There are many very high quality options, from so many manufacturers.
As already said, none of these holsters will work as designed, unless they are carried with a quality, no-stretch belt, that fills the belt slot.
As you can see, the Serpa pictured is for a full length 1911, and therefore hangs an inch farther down your leg. The same holster is made for the Commander-length 1911.
Here's the shorter version Serpa for the Commander-length 1911...
And a holster I've misplaced since soon after I bought it, (I finally found it :mrgreen
, this holster is one of the finest I've ever owned. Made by Chuck 100 yd from this forum. Not necessarily a high-ride holster, but seems to work out as concealable as any other Commander-size holster I've ever used...
...
WAYNO.