JackBull
Blackhawk
I am hearing that SW and in particular the Ultimate J Frame is having some QC issues. Since my wife is considering buying one for SD, I have some concerns. Anyone else here the same or is this internet BS.
SW Ultimate J Frame
- Thread starter JackBull
- Start date
Help Support Ruger Forum:
contender
Ruger Guru
I don't follow S&W stuff much,, as most of my S&W's are older. So,,, I can't say anything about any QC issues with one of their models. But,, since I'm a bit more of a Ruger fan,, I'd offer a polite thought; Why not give the Ruger LCR a chance?
I offer that thought,, all while knowing as an instructor,, I tell people to find a gun that fits THEM,, not me. If your wife really likes the J-frames,, then let her make the decision.
I offer that thought,, all while knowing as an instructor,, I tell people to find a gun that fits THEM,, not me. If your wife really likes the J-frames,, then let her make the decision.
I have picked up these 5 j frames in the last couple years and they have all been most excellent. Of course the lcr's have been as well.
The Kimber is pretty much flawless but not quite in the same class because of the weight.
Pál_K
Single-Sixer
My S&W Model 60 J-frame in .357 magnum. It's heavy enough that lighter .357 bullets (125 grain?) in a full .357 magnum power load are pleasant to shoot. Bought new in 2010; I'm very happy with it. No issues at all.
JackBull
Blackhawk
All my revolvers are Rugers. The LCR is a little too large for my wife's pockets so she is thinking J frame. The new SW is in 32 H&R which is also nice.
contender
Ruger Guru
Understood.
As an instructor for many ladies only handgun clinics,, we always preach; "Don't let anyone else pick out a gun for you. YOU find the one that YOU like, and the one YOU will carry, and the one that fits YOU & YOUR hands. Just make sure it's a quality firearm you can bet your life on!"
As an instructor for many ladies only handgun clinics,, we always preach; "Don't let anyone else pick out a gun for you. YOU find the one that YOU like, and the one YOU will carry, and the one that fits YOU & YOUR hands. Just make sure it's a quality firearm you can bet your life on!"
If you like your K6S you need to try the K6XS. For carry it is wonderful.
That is a nice Chris Reeves folder to go with your Kimber!
I have been looking at the K6XS. It weighs 15.9ounces and mine weighs 23 ounces. But it only shoots 38 special. But I do like it.
Had to look it up, ah, Ultimate carry they call it. A really neat piece IMO. Wouldn't mind having one myself. The 32 might be perfect for a woman as a 16 oz. revolver can sting a bit in 38. But if she can handle that, it's all good.
Yes, contender is 100% spot on that the owner/shooter has to decide. If she likes it I'd have her try one & see. As far as QC issues? I won't say they are without them, nor will I say they are rash with them either. Let one person have trouble & they're crying/reporting anywhere they can. If one passes a good once over upon receiving it, or buying it if you have that option, then first time at the range should pretty much indicate if it's good to go. Heck, the shooter might even decide it's not for her.
Curious as to where you heard of the issues too. Helps to know who is saying something.
Yes, contender is 100% spot on that the owner/shooter has to decide. If she likes it I'd have her try one & see. As far as QC issues? I won't say they are without them, nor will I say they are rash with them either. Let one person have trouble & they're crying/reporting anywhere they can. If one passes a good once over upon receiving it, or buying it if you have that option, then first time at the range should pretty much indicate if it's good to go. Heck, the shooter might even decide it's not for her.
Curious as to where you heard of the issues too. Helps to know who is saying something.
Some 38+P is 125 @ 1250 and that'll do the job too.
I do agree, it will certainly do the job.
$750 out the door.
JackBull
Blackhawk
"Since my wife is considering buying one for SD..."
Similar threads
