BlkHawk73, Take a look at the "tip" of the spring that contacts the loading gate "stud". You may have to "round" that off as well as "smoothing" that portion of the stud it contacts. Another thing to look at: does the gate move "freely" without the spring installed. Also, you "will" have slight movement of the gate when it is "closed" (with spring installed) because of a lesser spring pressure. However, when it is "opened", heavier spring pressure is present and there should not be any appreciable movement of it. I have found these gate "problems" can sometimes get very tedious in correcting them that's why I like to carry a good supply of springs! By swapping springs around you can sometimes come up with the right combination you are looking for. I doubt you over-compressed the spring as they are quite resilient. This calls for one of them times when you have to really "study" what the gun is doing (how it's acting) to come up with the proper correction. If you have another Blackhawk, you can try it's gate and spring in the Maximum to see how "that" combination works..................................Dick