Redhawk and Super Blackhawk Opinions

Help Support Ruger Forum:

On the Redhawks models, I have no interest in the newer ones with shorter barrels, etc. My interest in them is with the "originals" that only came as 5.5 inch and 7.5 inch.

With those, the more desirable items are calibers 357 magnum and 41 magnum. Some like the 45 Colts too. The 7.5 inch "Hunter" models with the scope ring cutouts on the barrel are really sought after by some too. I prefer the blue models even though they seem for now to not bring as much money as stainless.
 
On the Redhawks models, I have no interest in the newer ones with shorter barrels, etc. My interest in them is with the "originals" that only came as 5.5 inch and 7.5 inch.

With those, the more desirable items are calibers 357 magnum and 41 magnum. Some like the 45 Colts too. The 7.5 inch "Hunter" models with the scope ring cutouts on the barrel are really sought after by some too. I prefer the blue models even though they seem for now to not bring as much money as stainless.
I had tried a 5.5" RH and loved it. Good feel and balance. I chose the 7.5 incher with the ring cutouts because I wanted to scope it for deer hunting. Turned out after setting it up I found it to be too muzzle heavy with the scope. It's now fitted with a reflex sight and that makes it perfect. Regardless, if a deal came up I would go with either barrel length.

In the case of a Super BH, a 7.5 incher is the ONLY way to go.

As far as being more collectible or desirable, if you find a 1976 model roll marked with "Made in the 200th year of Liberty", DON'T let that one get away.
 
Odd to buy both. Collectors might want both, but I'd submit most hunters, shooters etc. have a preference for one or the other. I have a double action revolver background and have big bore Redhawks and Blackhawks. But for hunting and fun I love the single action. It's lighter especially mine in .45 with the aluminum grip frame (super Blackhawk .44 is steel) and I love the feel and ergonomics. It just makes my Redhawk feel blocky, heavy and crude. I do carry a 4". Redhawk for bear, moose protection though. I agree with the others the prices he's quoting are pretty much full price. You can easily do better. Especially on the Blackhawk.
 
"Should" sell for is a loaded question. I overwhelmingly go for single actions and have overpaid for Blackhawks (BH) and don't mind it if I get what I want.

Luckily many BH's are currently available in most calibers, barrel lengths, and metal type and new samples won't break most banks, if they do, used prices are about 10% or more less than new.

Even when I had a Redhawk, I didn't care for it, and not until the Super Redhawk came out did I break down and get one though I doubt I'd need or want another.
 
Welcome to the Forum!

Both guns are good, desirable to many, and if used, are enjoyable to shoot.

You mentioned that you'd be shooting/using them, so collecting isn't an issue.
You mentioned so many variations,, and you are correct. Collectors look for specific variations,, and as such,, you can see prices for specific models be quite a bit higher than others.
If you are going to buy just one of them, YOU have to know which one fits YOUR hands the best and that YOU shoot the best.
If you can buy both,, I'd say "Why not? "

But trying to wait & low-ball an offer just because you may feel it's too much,, may not be the best idea either. A good solid BHK is easily worth $500-$600 for a NM like the one shown. And a Redhawk is easily worth $600-$700 to many in general. So a FAIR price would be in the $1100-$1200 range for the pair.
As mentioned above; "You may think think you paid too much,, but in reality, you may pay a little too early." They won't go down in value,, as long as you take care of them.
I learned long ago that if something is offered at a fair price,, pay it w/o haggling. That way,, if it's worth more than the offered sale price,, the seller can't get upset later on because you beat them down on the price. If the offering is in the middle of the road,, then a LITTLE bit of very POLITE haggling may be ok. But if too high,, then a counter offer isn't out of line.
 
I think your dreaming if you think you will get a fairly good gun for $600. What you probably will get is a gun that has been shot thousands of times, maybe scratched up or even dented, may have hidden issues. Redhawks are the best guns that Ruger makes, just look at Gun Broker for USED prices. I was very lucky in my search for a NEW 5.5", 44mag, SS RedHawk and came across one for $1K. Previously I picked up a Super Redhawk 7.5", 44mag SS for about $1K also. You will see that most of the Redhawks listed on Gun Broker are listed for $1200 to $1400 and are USED. So those prices should tell you something, that one listed for $600 will be a piece of crap gun. Of course this is MY opinion.
 
Larry that's sounds expensive. The new RedHawks are less than the prices you are quoting for used ones. Brand new on buds for an ss 5.5 RH with free shipping is $1034 or make offer. Those prices you mentioned on gunbroker are guns that just sit there and don't sell. If you click the most recently sold box on search you can see what stuff has actually sold for. Just wanted to chime in to help this new member save some cash.

Something else to consider is FFL fees charged by your local shops. Here in Alaska it's $20-$25. In Cali where my brother lives it's $100-$150 so maybe buying local and paying a higher price is the route you take. Most shops if you buy through them don't tack on the NICs paperwork costs, some might? My area they don't. Just some things to consider.
 
Last edited:
Thanks! I did look at the sold for prices on GB when getting my information together. People can ask whatever they want for something. Only the sold listing is where is check things. Real world prices on my opinion.

I am glad you brought up the fees, etc. that should be taken into consideration. That is exactly what I did when doing my research. My local shop that is listed as an FFL dealer on the site that can receive the package only charges $25. He is an acquaintance and may do a better deal for me but even at $25 it is not an issue. I also have to take into consideration any shipping charges. Things like this add up quick and buying local can save money in the long run.
 
Good topic, too bad I spent all day in the big city for medical appointments.

Can't really add to what's already been said, as the other members pretty much covered everything. I will say though both SA and DA Ruger 44 mags are one of my favorites pistols to shoot. My all time favorite, and still the most fun to shoot is the standard SBH with a 7.5" bbl. It's the one I'm most accurate with free handed as well. Friends hate it when I shoot better with their SBH than they do, there's no more blaming the gun ;) .

Pick one and enjoy! 😊

IMG_0668.jpeg
 
Good topic, too bad I spent all day in the big city for medical appointments.

Can't really add to what's already been said, as the other members pretty much covered everything. I will say though both SA and DA Ruger 44 mags are one of my favorites pistols to shoot. My all time favorite, and still the most fun to shoot is the standard SBH with a 7.5" bbl. It's the one I'm most accurate with free handed as well. Friends hate it when I shoot better with their SBH than they do, there's no more blaming the gun ;) .

Pick one and enjoy! 😊

View attachment 60492
Amazing collection. This is what I know will happen to me. Get my first one and down the rabbit hole I go.
 

Latest posts

Top