graygun said:
gramps said:
.....
....The Garand uses clips.
As does the 1903, 03-A3, and Mausers. The M1 Carbine, M-14 and M1A can use either for reloading if there's an empty (or partially depleted) magazine in place...as-can my personal (582-Series) Mini-14, which has a receiver-mounted 'clip guide' very similar to what is found on an M-14.
All that said...all repeating rifles have a magazine, be it blind, tubular, rotary, fixed, a removable box or whatever...for that's the term for the portion of the gun it's ammo gets loaded into. Only real difference in any of 'em from the user's standpoint is that some are designed to be quickly removable/replaced but most are not. Of the latter, most sporting rifle magazines must be loaded one round at a time until it's full, and most military rifles can be loaded with what is commonly called a "stripper clip".
There are exceptions to that, the Stoner platform being a prime example. And as you have pointed out, the M1 Garand...which is 'one off' design in that the "clip" it uses could have just as accurately have been called a 'half magazine'...meaning that the body of it's clip is actually/functionally a part of it's magazine Ass'y, sans the spring and follower of course (which remain in the gun).
Conclusion:
All repeating rifles have a magazine, but not all are designed to use a clip.
So yeah, words do mean things. Plus, some words require additional words in order to paint a correct picture...as-in, there's quite a difference in a "fixed magazine", "replaceable box magazine" and "tubular magazine", just as there's a difference in an "en bloc clip" and a "stripper clip".
It sometimes helps when we know what the other guy is talking about, that's all I'm trying to get at here...No offense meant to anyone.
DGW