It really depends which diameter shoots the best in your gun. You will have to experiment a bit.
Most (all?) jacketed bullets will be .429 diameter. The majority of the cast bullets out there will be sized to .430 and some will be sized to .431.
My pistols (Redhawks and Blackhawks) seem to prefer cast bullets in the .430 diameter and I have had really consistent results with the Lazercast 300 grain bullets. They simply shoot very well in my Redhawks.
As mentioned by captainkirk some firearms will prefer the .431 diameter bullets.
If you haven't loaded for pistol calibers before I would absolutely second the recommendation to use carbide dies -- eliminates the step of lubing cases and the step required to clean them up later. I have used Lyman, RCBS, Lee, and Dillon carbide dies at different times. I am a big fan of the Dillon dies! They are set up for quick adjustment, and quick cleaning or changing the seating plug without having to remove the die from the press -- literally takes just seconds to remove and replace. If you load a lot of cast bullets you will come to appreciate how handy this feature is as bullet lube collects against the seating stem and changes your seating depth. I tend to load a thousand or more rounds at a time for the .44 and just really like how quick and easy the Dillon dies are to use.
Any quality carbide set of dies will make your experience much more pleasant -- do your homework and choose the set that will best serve your purposes.
Dave