I agree absolutely. I have version 1 of the LC9. I have a tight fit OWB Galco/Viridian ECR and an ECR IWB holster that is much looser than than the OWB. I have no problem being in battery in either holster. I did have an 'in-battery' problem when I tried flat nose FMJ rounds but no problem with...
Are you looking for IWB or OWB?
I carry an LC9 both IWB, OWB holsters. Since I use a Viridian Green Laser sight, I use ECR holsters. My IWB and OWB holsters are both made by Galco. Both are vertical. The OWP is a paddle holster. I prefer a vertical holster. You might want to look at Galco...
I have my LC9 for a few weeks now, and I have fired over 100 rounds with it. I have had no issues with the magazine. In fact the magazine eject button requires a firm push to release the magazine. My guess is that the rental gun has a lot of wear and tear. I am enrolled in several Ruger forums...